Despite significantly different immigration enforcement climates in Texas and Rhode Island, a majority of surveyed Latino high school students in both states fear someone close to them could be arrested and deported. And more than half in both states reported symptoms of mental health conditions such as anxiety, depression or post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) at levels significant enough to warrant treatment, according to a new study by the Migration Policy Institute (MPI) in collaboration with the University of Houston and Rhode Island College.
The researchers conducted and analyzed surveys completed by hundreds of Latino students at 11 high schools in Harris County and Rhode Island during the 2018-2019 school year, and interviewed dozens of education professionals, mental health and other service providers, local elected officials, advocates and community organizers.
The study examines the links between immigration enforcement and the related fears and mental health of Latino youth. These children, who represent about one-quarter of all high school students nationwide, report fears of immigration enforcement that result in mental-health conditions that hold potential consequences for their school engagement, academic achievement and future success in the workforce and in life more generally.
Jodi Berger Cardoso, associate professor at the UH Graduate College of Social Work, led the research effort in Harris County. For more than 15 years, Cardoso has examined how exposure to trauma and psychosocial stress before, during and post-migration affects the mental health of Latino immigrants and their children.
“We need to understand how immigration policy at the national level is having direct negative consequences on the well-being of children, including their development and mental health,” she said.
The survey explored students’ fears of and exposure to immigration enforcement, as well as other stressors such as trauma, discrimination and economic hardship; personal strengths such as resilience, spirituality and family support; symptoms of anxiety, depression and PTSD; and substance use.
Among the top findings:
- More than half of the students reported symptoms of mental-health conditions at levels high enough to warrant treatment. Two-thirds of the sample met the clinical threshold that would warrant treatment for anxiety, 58% for PTSD and 55% for depression. Students were as likely to report symptoms of mental health conditions in Rhode Island as in Harris County, despite higher levels of enforcement fear in the latter. (U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, or ICE, made more arrests in Harris County in fiscal 2018 than any other U.S. county. Rhode Island, by contrast, has a relatively low level of ICE activity and has state policies restricting local law enforcement cooperation with the federal agency.) Students who feared immigration enforcement most acutely—and who changed their behaviors as a result—had the worst mental-health outcomes.
- Sixty-seven percent of students surveyed in Harris County and 52% in Rhode Island feared that someone close to them would be arrested and deported; 56% knew someone who had been deported.
- One-third of the sample reported they were afraid that they would be deported themselves—including 12% of U.S.-born students surveyed.
- Thirty percent reported changing their behavior as a result of deportation fears, including by avoiding driving, going to the doctor, attending religious services or participating in afterschool activities; taking a different route to school; and staying at home more often. These behavior changes were reported equally by immigrant and U.S.-born students.
- Latino students who are U.S. born reported experiencing more traumatic events over their lifetimes than those who are immigrants: 8.1 traumatic events versus 6.9, respectively. Although Central American migrants face well-documented trauma in their home countries and en route to the United States, U.S.-born youth have longer exposure to high levels of crime in the low-income, generally urban communities included in the study. Common forms of trauma students reported were having someone close die, witnessing assault or being assaulted—at 73%, 72% and 42%, respectively.
The study findings suggest that state and local policies that limit cooperation with ICE, such as those in Rhode Island, may not entirely shield youth from the mental-health consequences associated with fear that someone they know could be detained and deported. The results may also owe to the fact that other stressors—traumatic experiences, economic hardship and discrimination—were roughly equally present in Harris County and Rhode Island.
“Given the well-documented link between mental health and student outcomes, supporting Latino students’ mental health at a time when many are experiencing heightened uncertainty and fear is an essential component of efforts to promote these students’ school engagement and academic achievement,” the report concludes. “In the current social and political environment, the stakes are high for Latino youth and for the society in which they will grow into adulthood, join the workforce, raise families and take part in civic life.”
The report, “Immigration Enforcement and the Mental Health of Latino High School Students,” can be read by clicking here.
The Migration Policy Institute (MPI) is an independent, non-partisan, non-profit think tank in Washington, DC dedicated to analysis of the movement of people worldwide. MPI provides analysis, development and evaluation of migration and refugee policies at local, national and international levels.